American Art Review Study Project
Volumes XI through XVI
1. agree with TFAO to handle a number of agreed upon texts.
- Recovery matrix composite
scores of 1, 2, 4 and 5 indicate information desirable
for the TFAO digital library or heightened probability of republishing.
Texts with these favorable scores will be pursued for republishing. Scores
of 3, 6, 7, 8 and 9 indicate substantial information already available
in the TFAO digital library or through external links, or low probability
of republishing. Texts with these unfavorable scores will not be pursued.
- TFAO's experience is that approximately 1/2 of texts
worked on with favorable recovery matrix composite
scores result in permissions granted. The most likely reason for permissions
not obtained is inability to find the owner of the text. Less likely reasons
are apathy or reluctance on the part of the owner in having the text republished
or inability of the author to remember the ownership of the text or confusion
as to ownership.
- Issues of American Art Review are usually available
in university libraries if the university has an art history department.
Issues may also be available at public libraries, art museum libraries
and at art dealers. Often the issues are in the library's reference department
and cannot be checked out, requiring photocopies to be made. The usual
library call number for the publication is: N6505 .A619 and the
ISSN number is 0092-1327. A public library's inter-library loan
department may be able to arrange for photocopies of pages from needed
American Art Review issues from another library that carries American
Art Review, subject to payment of a copying fee. Google searches and
searches in library websites will locate libraries carrying the magazine.
2. become familiar with TFAO's About
TFAO and Author Study and Index, plus
Resource Library's Services to institutions,
Scholarly text from private sources, and
Content presentation guidelines, It's good
to know -- if asked about viewership -- that TFAO's website is viewed by
millions of people each year and is the most viewed website in the world
devoted to American art. Sometimes it pleases an author or museum to know
that many new people will be exposed to their texts and that TFAO will enable
them to be more widely known. There are statistics at <http://tfaoi.org/aa/5aa/5aa49a.htm>.
3. determine the copyright ownership of each assigned American
Art Review text.
- TFAO has found it useful to read the biography of the
author of each text. Contact with authors many times easily solves the
question of copyright ownership of a text and the existence and ownership
of a related catalogue essay. The biography of the author for each text
is found in the back of each American Art Review issue. If the text
is related to an exhibition, there will be placed next to the text summary
information on the exhibition with the name of an exhibiting museum, its
address and phone number. The exhibiting museum may not be the organizing
museum. Organizing museums may hold copyrights, but exhibiting venues other
than organizers do not own them.
- For authors who are difficult to reach based on the biography
in the back of the American Art Review issue, searches in Google advanced search
and the Resource Library home page
may help identify the present whereabouts of the author. Also, if TFAO's
Author Study and Index indicates that the
author has written an article in American Art Review or another
magazine or journal published more recently, more recent issues may provide
the present whereabouts of the author.
- When speaking with an author, or co-authors, the volunteer
should ask of each who is the copyright holder or holders and confirm the
ownership which each party. If one of the authors can't be reached and
the author who is contacted claims full copyright ownership, the volunteer
may relay on the statement. If an author says that a museum owns or co-owns
the article, the volunteer confirms the museum's ownership or co-ownership
with the museum. If the author can't be reached, and the article is related
to a museum exhibit, a curator or director at a museum in some instances
may recall that the museum owns the article. Staff at small and medium-sided
museums are usually able and willing to research ownership.
- In instances where an American Art Review article
is a condensation of a catalogue essay, the author often states ownership
of the article and the museum or other publisher of the catalogue essay
as owner of the underlying essay. If ownership, or co-ownership, is determined
to be with a for-profit publisher, permission of the publisher is not sought.
- At the beginning or end of the American Art Review
text there may be a note indicating that it is a condensation or excerpt
from a catalogue essay. Often there is no clear indication of whether the
American Art Review text is an original article or essay, a condensation,
or a reprint of an essay. In instances where an American Art Review
article is found by the volunteer to be a condensation or excerpt of a
catalogue essay, the volunteer and TFAO may agree that the greatest value
to the public would be for the volunteer to seek the value derived from
republishing the original essay. An underlying essay may offer significantly
greater knowledge than is contained in the related American Art Review
text. In those cases pursuit of approvals to republish the article may
be agreed between the volunteer and the TFAO director to be a second choice
in favor of pursuing the underlying essay. The pursuit of approvals for
reprinting of related catalogue essays as first choice and in substitution
for reprinting of American Art Review articles is described at Related catalogue essays.
- Authors have repeatedly stated that articles written
by them and published by American Art Review during the first study
period are owned by the authors since they received no compensation from
American Art Review. In some instances authors cannot remember who
holds the copyright to an article. In infrequent instances authors will
say that they were compensated by American Art Review.
- When speaking with an author, the volunteer should verify
that the author was not compensated by American Art Review and that
the author believes that the magazine is not owner of the article. If an
author does not remember whether or not he or she received compensation
from American Art Review, or believes that American Art Review
may be the owner or co-owner for any other reason, pursuit of permission
for republishing is discontinued. In cases of uncertainty TFAO does not
subsequently ask American Art Review to research whether or not
an author was compensated for an articles published by it, does not seek
its permission for republishing the article, and does not republish the
article. If the author says that an entity other than American Art Review
is the owner, the volunteer will seek the permission of the owner.
- In early 2004 conversations between TFAO and Thomas Kellaway,
publisher of American Art Review, Mr. Kellaway stated American
Art Review's acceptance of Resource Library reprintings of articles
owned by others, as long as TFAO contacts and gains permissions from the
owners of articles, accompanying images of art objects are not reprinted,
and .pdf images of entire pages are not published by Resource Library.
TFAO extends courtesy to American Art Review through an editor's
note for each article by stating the issue in which the article appeared
in American Art Review and providing a link to the American Art
- Permissions are sought after ownership is established
when speaking with each party who claims ownership of an article, except
for those instances where the permissions process is discontinued, as explained
- The volunteer may wish to keep field notes on some type
of progress form. Click here for a printable
copy of a form found in the past to be useful by TFAO in keeping notes.
4. secure permission with copyright owners for TFAO to
- Before seeking approvals of copyright owners, the volunteer
should become familiar with TFAO's page on Acquisition
and deselection of content for the TFAO-dl.
This page provides reassurance to copyright owners through TFAO's promises
regarding republishing of texts. TFAO's sample letters
may be of benefit to the volunteer in phrasing emails or conversation with
- Email letters are best preceded by phone conversations
confirming the ownership of texts.
- TFAO will not send paper copies of online-printed texts
to owners. Links will be sent by TFAO as a courtesy when requested.
- TFAO has found that referrals to the rights and reproductions
departments of museums are almost always errors on the part of the museum.
If copyright owners challenge the legitimacy of the volunteer's relationship
with TFAO they may call TFAO or send an email to TFAO's director for verification.
TFAO will be pleased to provide an email letter of introduction for the
benefit of the volunteer.
5. arrange for copyright owners to send permissions emails
directly to TFAO (with CCs to the volunteer) indicating their approvals
for republishing online in Resource Library.
- The final approval emails from the copyright owners are
to be for one time publication in Resource Library,
6. obtain from copyright owner or author text in .doc format
in accordance with Submitting materials.
7. email to TFAO a complete presentation package for each
fully processed text to include:
- a. forwarded email letter of the volunteer's CC copy
of the permission from the copyright owner previously sent to TFAO
- b. text in .doc format in accordance with Submitting
- c. "about the author" text. For author information
the volunteer provides either what the text's owner sends to the volunteer
or uses basic facts from the American Art Review biography such
as: "At the time of writing of the above article [author name] was
the [job title] at the [name of employer]."
- d. Resource Library page header for the article
indicating contact information for comments or for securing reprints and
the "Editor's note" for the bottom of the page which includes
acknowledgements for assistance in gaining permissions and other information.
- For the page header TFAO first states the date of permission
and the owner of the text. TFAO always wants the reader to have a means
of reaching the text owner directly (valid at time of publication as TFAO
does not update owner info later on) -- without contacting TFAO. TFAO does
not want readers contacting it (usually years later) with the intent of
TFAO trying to figure out how to route them to the source. TFAO only provides
author/owner's personal information such as email addresses and phone numbers
if they expressly want TFAO to do so. Otherwise, regarding author
owners, TFAO publishes only the employer's postal address, or web site
and/or phone number. Sometimes TFAO publishes information on the last known
place of employment as the last resort. Here is a page header example:
- Editor's note: The following text was reprinted
in Resource Library on [month, day, year] with the permission of
[name of copyright holder]. If you have questions or comments regarding
the text, please contact [name of copyright holder] directly through this
[phone number] and [address]:
- [phone number]
- [website or other address]
- TFAO will add gray color to the text at its office.
- For the "Editor's note" TFAO repeats part of
the header regarding the permission. Then the date of permission is added.
If applicable, reference is then made to an exhibition related to the article.
The reference to American Art Review should be as stated in the
example. TFAO mentions American Art Review as a courtesy and publishes
a link to its website. Lastly, TFAO acknowledges who helped gain the permission.
If the article was published in whole earlier in a catalogue or brochure,
this first instances of publication is noted. Here is an "Editor's
- Resource Library
- The above text was reprinted in Resource Library
on [month, day, year] with permission of [name of copyright holder],
which was granted to TFAO on [month, day, year]. [author's name]'s article
pertains to [name and dates of exhibition if applicable]. This text was
also published in the [month/year] issue of American
- Resource Library
wishes to extend appreciation to [name of volunteer plus any other persons
who helped gain permission] for [her/his/their] help concerning permission
for reprinting the above text.
- At TFAO's office TFAO will activate a link to American
Art Review's website and add a disclaimer after the "Editor's
note that says:
- Links to sources of information outside
of our web site are provided only as referrals for your further consideration.
Please use due diligence in judging the quality of information contained
in these and all other web sites. Information from linked sources may be
inaccurate or out of date. TFAO neither recommends or endorses these referenced
organizations. Although TFAO includes links to other web sites, it takes
no responsibility for the content or information contained on those other
sites, nor exerts any editorial or other control over them. For more information
on evaluating web pages see TFAO's General
Resources section in Online
Resources for Collectors and Students of Art History. Individual pages
in this catalogue will be amended as TFAO adds content, corrects errors
and reorganizes sections for improved readability. Refreshing or reloading
pages enables readers to view the latest updates.
Return to Volunteer Relationship
Copyright 2011 Traditional Fine Arts Organization, Inc., an Arizona nonprofit corporation. All rights